All posts by Sylvia Schwarz

Grants from the Israeli Consulate Should be Returned

This article was originally published by the Minnesota Spokesman Recorder on December 30, 2021.

The Israeli Consulate in Chicago announced Social Impact grants to three Minneapolis-based organizations, and held a ceremony on Thursday, December 9 to distribute the $5,000 checks to A Mother’s Love, Mr. Basketball Academy, and Minnesota STEM Partnership.

The irony of awarding “Social Impact” grants is astounding. This has been a year when the Israeli Defense Force (IDF) has killed hundreds of Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank, many of them children, demolished homes in Jerusalem and in the Naqab (Negev) desert, denied Palestinians the COVID vaccine, denied them freedom of movement, education, health care, water, livelihood, and arrested dozens of children from their beds at night.

In October, Israel declared that six human rights organizations are “terrorist” organizations, severely restricting their operations and funding.

What could motivate Israel to give American human rights organizations grants? Israel is suffering a public relations setback, which was exacerbated by their bombing of Gaza in May. Human rights abuses within Israel and the occupied territories have only intensified since then. Israel used to be able to apply oppression with impunity, but now there is increased awareness of the situation in the United States.

A growing number of US citizens are becoming sympathetic to Palestinians, and even favorable opinions of the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement are increasing. (The BDS movement attempts to compel Israel to comply with international law through economic, cultural, and educational boycotts and divestment.)

Clearly, Israel feels the need to counter this growing sentiment in the US by showing its support for “social justice”–everywhere except in Israel.

Make no mistake: Israel targets Palestinians simply because they are Palestinians. The 2018 “Nation State Law,” one of the Basic Laws which substitute for Israel’s constitution, clearly states that non-Jews do not have the same rights in Israel as Jews. This law is Israel’s admission that it practices apartheid, as two human rights organizations (B’Tselem and Human Rights Watch) laid out in separate reports in 2021.

Do the three organizations receiving grants from Israel really want to accept money from an apartheid state? Do they want to do public relations work for a country whose laws enshrine Jewish supremacy?

In my world, social justice means equality. These Minneapolis organizations are working towards equality, healing from past and present injustices, and community uplifting. But those values are contradictory to all that Israel stands for–ethnic supremacy, settler colonialism, and apartheid.

Organizations working for social justice should not accept money from countries working for injustice and inequality. The three community organizations that received grants should return the money. This should be done publicly and loudly, proclaiming that, n the words of Martin Luther King, Jr., “injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.”

Ben & Jerry’s Ice Cream – #OneSmallScoopForJustice

Recently, Ben & Jerry’s Ice Cream announced that it would stop selling its product in illegal settlements in the Occupied West Bank (see articles here and here). The predictable backlash came immediately (see here, for example). Israeli envoy Gilad Erdan even asked US governors to activate their unconstitutional anti-boycott laws enacted in more than 30 states to punish Ben & Jerry’s and its parent company, Unilever. (Erdan made this request of the governors of all the states with anti-boycott laws, so we assume Governor Walz was one of them. There is no confirmation of this, though).

Let’s not wait to find out what Minnesota’s governor will do! We’ve started a social media campaign called #OneSmallScoopForJustice. Post a photo of yourself enjoying some Ben & Jerry’s ice cream  with that hash tag!

You can also put a bumper sticker on your car:

For a donation of at least $7.00 (which includes shipping and handling), we will send you one of these beautiful bumper stickers. Just click the button below and enjoy your One Small Scoop For Justice!

Please be sure to complete the shipping field!

… otherwise, we won’t know where to ship your beautiful sticker…

Deadly Exchange: Israel and US Policing

Since 2002, thousands of US law enforcement officials have trained with Israeli military forces in the context of the “War on Terror,” learning about Israeli methods and technologies of surveillance, racial profiling, and suppression of protest. As Black Lives Matter and other social movements seek accountability and an end to police violence, why are US police departments training with occupying Israeli forces? How do we resist the militarization of police and the criminalization of US citizens and immigrants? And how is the movement for Justice in Palestine organizing for justice and real safety from the US to Palestine?

Speaker Eran Efrati is the executive director of Researching the American-Israeli Alliance (RAIA), and an investigative researcher into the Israeli military and arms industry. He has worked with the International Criminal Court and participated in both independent and UN investigations into Israeli military operations. His investigative reports have appeared in The New York Times, The Washington Post, and The Guardian, among others. He currently serves as chair of the board for Jewish Voice for Peace, and his research focuses on military and police partnerships between the United States and Israel.

Thursday, August 12, 2021, 7 PM

Zoom: https://us06web.zoom.us/j/83334769540Facebook.com/WomenAgainstMilitaryMadness youtube.com/WomenAgainstMilitaryMadnesstwitter.com/WAMMwomen

When a Minnesota Law Silences Us

 

Two Minnesota laws, passed in 2017, prohibit the Legislature or any State Agency from contracting with any business or vendor that supports BDS or “discriminates against Israel.” Similar laws in states across the U.S. violate free speech rights protected by the 1st Amendment. Learn about the laws and efforts to have them repealed.

             Featured Speaker: Meera Shah Senior Staff Attorney, Palestine Legal

Register: HERE

For Information: mn@breakthebonds.org

Co-hosts: American Muslims for Palestine–MN, Jewish Voice for Peace–Twin Cities, MN BDS Community, Middle East Peace Now, MN Break the Bonds, MN Friends of Sabeel, Northfielders for Justice in Palestine/Israel, Palestine Israel Justice Project, Palestine Legal, Women Against Military Madness

Campaign to Repeal Minnesota’s Anti-BDS law: Update and Actions

Background:

In 2017 Minnesota was one of several states acting on legislation limiting our free speech rights to speak out against Israel’s policies and human rights abuses affecting Palestinians. Attempts to impose Federal legislation to restrict BDS activity had failed, and what followed was a very well-funded strategic campaign to achieve at the State level what could not at that time be achieved at the Federal level. Today 30 States have approved Anti-boycott legislation; and 24 states have approved legislation that impose boycott restrictions to be eligible for state contracts, including Minnesota.

Back in 2017 many diverse groups of individuals and organizations worked to stop the legislation from being enacted. Many people met with our legislators, wrote letters, held rallies, and spoke at legislative hearings to voice objections to this initiative, addressing both free speech and human rights concerns. The legislation still passed in Minnesota, but we raised the profile of the issues among Legislators and out in the community; we established partnerships in our community. The final language of the law was watered down from its initial wording, but make no mistake, it still restricts your freedom of speech!

Recently:

On February 12, 2021 the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that a similar anti-BDS law in Arkansas was unconstitutional. This on top of other First Amendment wins in Texas, Kansas and Arizona is more reason than ever to repeal Minnesota’s unconstitutional law!

We have organized with many other groups again to repeal Minnesota’s law and we have had some stunning successes! HF 1246 and SF 1039 have been introduced in the House and Senate, respectively, to do just that. They each have a number of co-authors, led by Rep. Steve Sandell and Sen. Mary Kunesh. Although we have found great support among the legislators to whom we have spoken, there is much more that needs to be done to actually get the bills to committees to be heard and then to the floors to be voted on.

TAKE ACTION TODAY!

We have an opportunity to repeal the legislation in Minnesota, and to add power to a national initiative to combat all such laws around the country. 

There is an aggressive campaign taking place now to equate BDS activity with antisemitism.

We expect that there will be a strong backlash against repeal of the Minnesota legislation, and it is important for us to work together in collaboration if this is to be successful.

People working on this project have been meeting with their legislators to bring attention to this.

We are asking those in our community to raise your voices in support of repealing the Minnesota Anti-BDS law. Contact your legislators to let them know that you support repeal and urge them to attend a (virtual) information session about these bills on March 5, 2021 at 8:30 am. (Details will be here shortly. Please check back.)

Please let us know about your activities by sending an email to mn@breakthebonds.org so we can keep track of which legislators have been contacted, and so we can more effectively organize our actions.

This is an important time for us to act on this initiative. We need to be in touch with our Legislators so they hear from us before a backlash has a chance to take hold and affect opinions against repeal.

Download this flyer to communicate with others about the repeal initiative.

Let’s act now and Repeal the Minnesota Anti-BDS Law!

Thanks to Ruben Slomianski for the text of this post.

Admit it: The two-state solution for Palestine is dead

This article, by Mary Christine Bader, is reposted from a Minneapolis Star Tribune opinion piece, August 7, 2020.

It’s not democracy, it’s apartheid.

Support for the “two-state solution” is the pious cover invoked by senators and members of Congress whenever they are asked to support Palestinian rights. Our politicians talk about two states even though Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has long spoken of “less than a state” to describe his vision of a future for Palestinians who demand equal rights in their ancestral land.

Now, with Netanyahu promising to annex a third of the West Bank Palestinian territory, illegally occupied by Israel since 1967, we are at the end of the zombie two-state myth. The choice for Israel and for its U.S. supporters is now clear: an apartheid Jewish-supremacist nation with millions of Indigenous people denied self-determination, freedom of movement, equal justice and other basic human rights — or the alternative, two peoples with equal rights living together in one state.

Many Jews will regard the latter as failure of the utopian Zionist dream of creating an exclusively Jewish nation state in a land inhabited by others.

The Jewish writer Peter Beinart, once a loyal two-state liberal Zionist, recently horrified supporters of Israel with his articles in the New York Times and Jewish Currents confessing that he no longer believes in a Jewish state. For that, some Jews are calling him a traitor.

Beinart’s sin seems to be letting his humanity override his liberal Zionist instincts. He has now declared his belief in a single, binational state with equal rights for all, explaining in the New York Times: “I knew Israel was wrong to deny Palestinians in the West Bank citizenship, due process, free movement and the right to vote in the country in which they lived. But the dream of a two-state solution that would give Palestinians a country of their own let me hope that I could remain a liberal and a supporter of Jewish statehood at the same time.”

Beinart and many others have seen that hope extinguished by Israel’s relentless building of Jewish-only settler colonies on Palestinian lands throughout the West Bank territory that Israel has occupied for 53 years, in violation of existing international law. Israel’s formal annexation that is planned would leave only noncontiguous enclaves for Palestinians to inhabit in their ancestral lands, erasing all hope for a viable, independent state of their own.

“It’s time,” Beinart concluded, “to abandon the traditional two-state solution and embrace the goal of equal rights for Jews and Palestinians. It’s time to imagine a Jewish home that is not a Jewish state.”

Palestinians have been imagining such a state for a long time.

In his latest book, “The Hundred Years’ War on Palestine,” Columbia University historian Rashid Khalidi reframes the long struggle for control of Palestine as a colonial war on the Indigenous population that has rationally resisted displacement by Zionist settlers for more than a century.

“With the establishment of Israel” Khalidi writes, “Zionism did succeed in fashioning a potent national movement and a thriving new people in Palestine.” But, despite a campaign of Zionist terror and the ethnic cleansing of 750,000 Palestinians, the Zionist movement “could not fully supplant the country’s original population, which is what would have been necessary for the ultimate triumph of Zionism.”

The fundamental colonial nature of Israel in Palestine must be acknowledged, Khalidi writes, but “there are now two peoples in Palestine, irrespective of how they came into being, and the conflict between them cannot be resolved as long as the national existence of each is denied by the other. Their mutual acceptance can only be based on complete equality of rights, including national rights, notwithstanding the crucial historical difficulties between the two. There is no other possible sustainable solution, barring the unthinkable notion of one people’s extermination or expulsion by the other.”

In general, Americans have not viewed Israel as a domineering colonial power. And considering our own colonial history, some Americans think we have no right to criticize Israel. No matter that U.S. taxpayers provide at least $4 billion a year to support Israel, a prosperous country that is the largest recipient of our foreign aid.

Our representatives in Congress refuse to put conditions on this aid for Israel’s behavior, be it annexing occupied land or imprisoning Palestinian children. They justify unqualified support for Israel by saying it is the “only democracy in the Middle East.” It is, however, a country that does not provide equality to all its people. Israel grants full rights only to a specific ethno-religious group, and it denies all rights to millions of other people under its control. That is not the kind of democracy embedded in the U.S. Constitution. That is apartheid.

As Israel prepares to formally annex the most fertile, most water-rich third of the Palestinian West Bank, will America continue to enable Israeli apartheid and the Hundred Years’ War on Palestine? Or will we help birth a true democracy based on equal rights? That is our choice.

Mary Christine Bader is a writer in Wayzata.

New Campaign: Repeal Minnesota’s Anti-BDS Laws

Background:
In 2017, after debates in both chambers of the Minnesota legislature, including testimony from many members of MN BBC and other organizations against the bills, the legislature approved two bills and Governor Dayton signed them into law. These laws (MN Statutes 3.226 and 16C.053) prohibit the state and the legislature from entering into contract with an individual who boycotts Israel.

During the debates the legislators tried to smooth out the wording to make it appear that the purpose of the laws was not to restrict speech that is protected under the First Amendment of the US Constitution, but instead to protect Israel from discrimination, but the revised wording failed at both. The laws are unconstitutional because they condition receiving contracts based on a political view (this was determined in a Supreme Court ruling NAACP v Claiborne Hardware Store). Furthermore, the laws do nothing to prevent discrimination. Discrimination and hatred against people and ethnic or religious groups are things that we absolutely and wholeheartedly condemn. We believe in human rights for everybody. But really, what does it mean to discriminate against a country? This is non-sensical.

We support many boycotts and divestment from companies and entities profiting from human rights abuses. We support efforts to impose sanctions on countries, including Israel, which commit widespread human rights violations. We know that Boycotts, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) are non-violent tactics to pressure countries to end their human rights violations. We know these tactics work to bring bad behavior into the open and to educate people in our communities and around the world about what is really happening in Israel/Palestine. And because they are such effective tactics, pro-Israel organizations have been working very hard to criminalize constitutionally protected behavior in Minnesota and around the country.

Even though the laws are unconstitutional, they were enacted and exist now in Minnesota’s Statutes. We now have a new campaign to repeal the unconstitutional laws.

What you can do:

We have made contact with many of our state legislators and have found several House members and Senators who will introduce a bill to repeal those unconstitutional laws. Please contact your members (one Senator and one Representative) and urge them to sign on as co-sponsor, or to vote for repeal when it comes up for a vote. Go to this website and input your address to find your representatives. Then call those members’ legislative aids and explain why you think they should support repeal. To help in this, we have placed talking points here.

When you finish, please write a short email to mn@breakthebonds.org and tell us how it went. Be sure to name the legislator whose office you contacted, and what their reaction was.

Many thanks!

Your friends in solidarity,

MN Break the Bonds Campaign

Divest for Justice in Palestine!